✓ No Fix, No Cost

Est. 2008

Trade: Avoid Comebacks with 3 Essentials for Click Spring Replacement

Click spring replacement is usually necessary when the spring is broken, fatigued, or badly deformed, rather than simply misaligned. Many jobs need at least partial disassembly, often removing the ratchet wheel, to fit the new spring correctly. Unless your bench already has a mainspring winder, staking set and someone experienced in movement strips, the safer trade move is to send the job to a specialist workshop, rather than risk plate damage.


TL;DR:

  • Replacing a click spring typically requires disassembly and careful fitting to avoid damaging the plate or related components.
  • Always diagnose whether the spring is broken or just misadjusted before deciding on a replacement, as some issues can be resolved through cleaning and reseating.
  • Proper safety protocols, such as fully letting down the mainspring and using specialized tools, are essential to prevent spring or personal injury during repair.
  • Sending high-quality photos, details, and symptoms to a trade specialist ensures faster turnaround and reduces the risk of costly errors.
  • A successful repair relies on secure fitting, thorough testing, and documentation, with a guarantee that eliminates financial risk if the repair cannot be completed.

Watchrepairstation
Send Click Spring Repairs To Experts
Watch Repair Station handles trade watch repairs across the UK, with expert technicians, quick turnaround, and no financial risk if they cannot fix it.

Visit Watch Repair Station

Table of Contents

Diagnosing click spring failure and triage criteria for incoming jobs

Not every winding fault on the bench is a dead click spring. Knowing the difference saves you from stripping a movement that only needed a clean and a tweak.

Replacement is usually the right call when the spring slips under winding pressure and will not hold, or if there is visible damage such as a crack, missing tail, or worked loose tabs. These faults tend to get worse, not better, so a patch job rarely lasts.

Damaged click spring beside ratchet wheel

Adjustment can sometimes be enough when the spring has only lost a little tension, the tail is slightly bent rather than broken, or the seat is simply dirty and gumming up the action. A careful clean, reseat and light reshape can restore function without touching the fixings.

Before committing either way, run a quick triage on every incoming job:

  • Photograph the movement and the click assembly from more than one angle before touching anything.
  • Note the calibre and manufacturer, since fixings and tab designs vary widely between movements.
  • Record the exact symptom (slipping, grinding, no resistance) rather than a general description of “winding problems”.
  • Flag urgency and estimate the risk of plate damage before deciding whether to open the movement.

That last point matters more than it sounds. A movement with a worn or previously repaired plate hole is a different risk profile to a clean, unmolested one, and it should change your decision on whether to attempt the job in house.

Step by step professional replacement: safety, disassembly, fitment and testing

Once you have decided replacement is needed, the sequence matters as much as the parts. Rushing the early steps is where most comebacks start.

Pro Tip: Never work on a barrel or ratchet assembly while the mainspring is still under tension: let it down fully and safely before removing anything.

  1. Let down the mainspring completely and secure the movement in a movement holder before any disassembly begins.
  2. Decide whether you need to remove the ratchet wheel alone or the full barrel assembly. On movements with a crimped wheel, you will need to open the crimp itself, so plan for that extra step, as detailed for Hermle style sprocket wheels.
  3. Remove the old spring. Depending on the fixing, this means punching out rivets, unsoldering an old repair, or carefully prising back a crimped rim rather than forcing it.
  4. Check the plate hole and tabs for wear before fitting anything new. Practitioners on watch and clock forums note that some click springs use tabs driven into the plate as an interference fit, and forcing a slightly oversized tab into a worn hole is a common source of damage.
  5. Fit the new spring in the correct orientation and secure the tabs, either by staking or bradding them in place, or by using a screw or tap fixing where the original design allows it.
  6. Re-crimp or close any wheel you opened, working gradually rather than in one movement, to avoid distorting the rim.
  7. Reassemble the barrel and train, then run a controlled winding test followed by a run test to confirm the click is holding and the watch is keeping steady time.

The barrel work in steps two and six is where a proper mainspring winder earns its keep. Handling a tensioned or partially wound spring by hand risks both the spring and your fingers, and BHI’s own training material on barrels and mainsprings treats correct tooling as standard practice rather than an optional extra.

The role the click spring plays is simple but unforgiving: it holds the click engaged with the ratchet teeth, and that engagement is what stops a wound barrel spinning back and dumping its power the moment you let go of the crown, as BHI’s own technical notes describe. A spring that is even slightly wrong in tension or seating will show up immediately under a winding test, which is why that final check is never optional.

Practical fixes to fitment problems and when to opt for assembly replacement

Small snags are common even on a routine click spring job, and most have a known fix rather than a reason to abandon the repair.

  • Oversized tabs should be filed back gently or the plate hole prepared to suit, never forced into an undersized seat.
  • Support the spring properly during staking and use controlled, progressive pressure rather than one heavy blow, which is the fastest way to crack a new spring.
  • Damaged pivots or a worn arbor usually mean replacing the whole wheel rather than fitting a spring into a compromised housing.
  • If wear extends beyond the click assembly into the barrel or train, stop and recommend a full strip or overhaul rather than a localised fix.

Pro Tip: A thin strip of protective film over the plate while filing a tab keeps stray file marks off the brass, a small habit forum contributors repeatedly flag as cheap insurance.

Parts, tooling and sourcing notes for reliable fitment

A click spring job is quick with the right kit and slow, or risky, without it.

  • Core tools: a mainspring winder, a staking set, hollow punches in several sizes, small drill bits for rivets, jeweller’s files and decent magnification.
  • Parts choice: a standalone click spring where the design allows, or a pre-assembled ratchet wheel where the spring is enclosed or crimped in place.
  • Fixings: rivet fixings suit original-style repairs, while shoulder screws can offer an easier, reversible fit on movements designed for them.
  • Sourcing: trade parts suppliers, donor movements, or a full replacement wheel assembly, which is often quicker and safer than reworking a worn original.

For crimped or fusee-style springs, restoration articles describe turning a replacement ring and drilling rivets by hand on a lathe-based repair, work that is accurate but equipment-heavy, and rarely worth it against sourcing a ready assembly for a trade turnaround.

Damage risks and a concise post-repair quality checklist

The main failure modes on a click spring job are marred plates from forcing an oversized tab, loose rivets from under-staking, and binding from a wheel that was re-crimped unevenly. All three are avoidable with patience rather than extra parts.

Before returning any watch, run through a short checklist:

  1. Hold test: wind fully and confirm the click holds with no slip or creep.
  2. Measured run check: let the watch run and confirm stable timekeeping rather than erratic gain or loss.
  3. Visual check of the staking or brad to confirm it sits flush with no distortion to the plate.
  4. Log the repair, including parts fitted and any plate work carried out, for warranty and comeback tracking.

If the case was opened or seals were disturbed during the job, water resistance testing before the watch goes back to the customer is worth building into your process.

Trade benefits of using a specialist and how Watch Repair Station handles click spring jobs

Click spring jobs reward specialist tooling and repetition, which is exactly what a trade-only workshop is built around. Working with a specialist partner means faster turnaround, no wasted bench time on a job your shop is not set up for, and no financial exposure if the repair is not viable.

When sending a job across, include:

  • Clear photographs of the movement and the affected assembly.
  • The movement calibre and manufacturer, where known.
  • A note of the symptoms observed and any previous repair attempts.

— efe

Send a click spring job to a trade partner built for it

Click spring work sits inside Movement Repairs, and if the fault turns out to run deeper once the movement is open, that scope can extend into a full Service & Overhaul without a second job or a second wait. Every job carries the “No Fix, No Cost” guarantee, so a spring that turns out to be unviable to fit costs your shop nothing.

Watchrepairstation

Sending work over is straightforward:

  • Package the watch securely with your triage notes attached (calibre, symptom, any prior repair history).
  • Include your own reference number so the job is easy to match back to your customer file.
  • Expect a fast turnaround built specifically around trade partners who cannot afford long wait times on customer watches.

Full details on scope and how to get started sit on our watch repair service page.

Sources

FAQ

Does replacing a click spring always mean stripping the movement?

Not always, but many jobs need at least the ratchet wheel removed to fit the new spring securely. Movements with crimped or enclosed wheels, such as some Hermle style designs, need the wheel opened rather than a simple in-place swap, as described in specialist repair guidance.

How do I know if a click spring needs replacing rather than adjusting?

A cracked spring, a missing tail or sheared tabs mean replacement, while slight tension loss or a dirty seat can often be fixed with a clean and reset. If the fault is getting worse between windings rather than staying stable, treat it as a replacement job.

What tools does a workshop need for click spring replacement?

A mainspring winder, a staking set, hollow punches, small drill bits and good magnification cover most jobs. Crimped or fusee-style wheels add lathe work for some repairs, which is one reason many trade shops send this work to a specialist rather than tooling up for occasional jobs.

What happens if a click spring job goes wrong on the bench?

The most common outcomes are a marred plate from forcing an oversized tab, a loose rivet from under-staking, or a binding wheel from uneven re-crimping. A “No Fix, No Cost” guarantee means a shop carries no financial risk if a job like this cannot be completed successfully.

Should a click spring repair include a water resistance check?

Only if the case was opened or seals were disturbed during the repair. In that case, a pressure test before the watch goes back to the customer is good practice to confirm the case is still sealed correctly.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *